Funding and Valuation

Startup Structuring in India: Co-Founder Equity, Ownership and Company Incorporation

Spread the love

When two or three people start a business together, the early decisions on ownership are usually made quickly, often on a handshake. Those decisions are hard to undo later. Who owns how much, what happens if a founder leaves, and how investors will come in are all settled at the very beginning, when the company is incorporated and the first shares are issued.

This article explains how startups in India commonly structure co-founder equity and ownership, and how that structure fits with company incorporation.

Most founders who plan to raise outside funding choose a private limited company. Investors, including angel investors and venture funds, generally invest only in companies, because a company can issue different classes of shares, convertible instruments and ESOPs.

StructureSuitsLimitation for a funded startup
Private limited companyStartups planning to raise equity, issue ESOPs or bring in foreign investorsMore compliance than an LLP or firm
LLPProfessional or service businesses with a few partnersCannot issue shares or ESOPs; venture investors rarely invest in LLPs
One Person CompanyA single founderOnly one member; needs conversion once a co-founder or investor joins
Partnership firmSmall family or local businessesUnlimited liability; not suitable for outside investment

A comparison of these options is in choosing a business structure for a startup, and the incorporation steps are in the company registration process in Kerala. For a service business with no funding plans, an LLP may be simpler.

2. Splitting equity between co-founders

There is no legal formula for the split. Founders usually weigh the following:

  • Role and time commitment: who is full time and who is part time or still employed elsewhere
  • Idea and early work: who built the product, prototype or customer base before incorporation
  • Capital brought in: cash invested by each founder
  • Skills that are hard to replace: technology, licences, industry relationships
  • Future responsibility: who will lead the company as CEO, CTO and so on

The problem with 50:50

An equal split between two founders feels fair, but it leaves no one with a deciding vote. Since ordinary resolutions need a simple majority and special resolutions need 75%, a disagreement between two 50% holders can stop the company from acting at all. If an equal split is chosen, the founders’ agreement should provide a way to break a deadlock, such as a casting vote for the chairperson on defined matters, mediation, or a buy-sell mechanism.

Capital contribution versus equity

Equity does not have to match the money each founder puts in. Shares are commonly issued at face value at incorporation (for example, ₹10 per share), and a founder who brings in more cash can be given a loan account or a separate class of shares instead of a larger stake.

3. Vesting and reverse vesting

Founder vesting protects the company if a co-founder leaves early. Instead of earning their shares over time, founders in India usually receive all their shares at incorporation, and the arrangement works as reverse vesting: if a founder leaves before a set period, the company or the other founders can buy back the unvested part at face value or a nominal price.

  • A common pattern is vesting over 4 years with a 1-year cliff (nothing vests if the founder leaves within the first year)
  • The terms are written into the founders’ agreement or shareholders’ agreement
  • To be enforceable against the company, the transfer and buy-back provisions should also be reflected in the Articles of Association
  • Any buy-back by the company itself must follow the Companies Act limits; a transfer to the remaining founders is often simpler

Good leaver and bad leaver

Agreements often treat a founder who leaves because of illness, death or a mutually agreed exit (good leaver) differently from one who leaves in breach of the agreement or is removed for misconduct (bad leaver). A good leaver may keep vested shares at fair value; a bad leaver may have to sell all shares at a nominal price.

4. Founders’ agreement and shareholders’ agreement

A founders’ agreement is signed between the co-founders, ideally before or soon after incorporation. A shareholders’ agreement (SHA) is usually signed when an investor comes in and often replaces or absorbs the founders’ agreement. Key points to cover:

  • Equity split and vesting
  • Roles, time commitment and salaries
  • Board seats and who appoints directors
  • Reserved matters that need all founders’ consent
  • Transfer restrictions: right of first refusal, lock-in, tag-along and drag-along
  • Deadlock resolution
  • Exit and leaver terms
  • Confidentiality and assignment of intellectual property

More detail is in important clauses in founders’ agreements and how to draft a shareholders’ agreement.

A note on non-compete clauses

Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes agreements in restraint of trade void. Courts in India have generally not enforced non-compete restrictions that apply after a person has left, though restrictions during the time a founder is with the company, and non-solicitation and confidentiality obligations, are treated differently. Founders should not rely only on a post-exit non-compete to protect the business.

5. Intellectual property belongs to the company

Code, designs, brand names and domain names created before incorporation often sit in a founder’s personal name. Investors will check that these have been assigned to the company in writing. An IP assignment deed from each founder, and an IP clause in every employment and consultancy contract, closes this gap. Trademark applications are better filed in the company’s name. See how startups can protect intellectual property.

6. Setting aside an ESOP pool

Startups often reserve 5% to 15% of the share capital as an employee stock option (ESOP) pool to attract key employees. The pool is created under Section 62(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 by a special resolution of the shareholders.

  • Normally, ESOPs cannot be granted to promoters or to directors who hold more than 10% of the shares
  • A startup recognised by DPIIT can grant ESOPs to such promoters and directors for up to 10 years from incorporation, under the share capital rules
  • Investors usually ask for the pool to be created before their investment, so that it dilutes the founders and not the investor

On valuation and tax aspects, see understanding ESOP valuation for startups.

7. How investors come in

Once outside money comes in, the founders’ stakes are diluted. The common instruments are:

InstrumentWhat it isPoints to note
Equity sharesOrdinary shares issued at a priceSimple, but the price fixes the valuation
CCPSCompulsorily convertible preference sharesCommon for angel and VC rounds; carry preference on liquidation and convert into equity later
CCDsCompulsorily convertible debenturesUsed in some rounds; treated as equity for FDI if fully and compulsorily convertible
Convertible notesMoney received as debt that converts into shares or is repaidAvailable to DPIIT-recognised startups subject to conditions, including a minimum amount of ₹25 lakh in a single tranche

Issue of shares to investors is done by private placement or preferential allotment, with a valuation report where required. Earlier, a premium above fair value could be taxed as income of the company under Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income-tax Act (the so-called angel tax). This provision was removed with effect from the financial year 2024-25, but valuation and FEMA pricing rules still apply. Preparing for the investor review is covered in preparing for investor due diligence.

8. Foreign co-founders and NRI founders

If a co-founder lives outside India or is a foreign national, the shares issued to them are foreign investment and must follow FEMA rules:

  • The sector must be open to foreign investment under the automatic route, or government approval is needed
  • Shares must be issued at or above the fair value set by the pricing guidelines
  • Money must come through banking channels, and reporting is done on the FIRMS portal within the time allowed
  • At least one director of the company must be resident in India

Some startups consider a flip, where the parent company is set up abroad and the Indian company becomes its subsidiary. A flip has tax, FEMA and overseas investment consequences for the Indian founders and is hard to reverse, so it should be studied carefully before the decision is made. See FDI in private limited companies and overseas direct investment compliance.

9. Board composition and control

Ownership and control are not the same. Control in a company sits with the board and with the shareholders voting on resolutions. Founders usually keep control through:

  • Holding more than 50% together, to pass ordinary resolutions
  • Holding more than 25% together, to block special resolutions
  • Board seats reserved for founders in the AOA and SHA
  • A list of reserved matters that need founder consent

10. Startup recognition

After incorporation, the company can apply for DPIIT recognition, which is needed for the ESOP relaxation and convertible notes mentioned above, and for tax and other benefits subject to conditions. Startups in Kerala can also register with the Kerala Startup Mission. See Kerala Startup Mission and startup recognition.

Points for startups in Kerala

  • Many Kerala startups begin with founders who are still employed or studying; the founders’ agreement should say clearly when each founder becomes full time
  • Where a founder is working abroad, especially in the Gulf, the FEMA points above apply to their shareholding
  • Family members are often brought in as initial shareholders; their role and exit should be documented in the same way as any other shareholder
  • Incubation programmes may take a small equity stake or have their own terms, which should be read alongside the founders’ agreement

Frequently asked questions

Is vesting of founder shares legally valid in India?

Yes, when it is structured as a contractual obligation in the founders’ agreement or SHA, supported by transfer provisions in the Articles of Association. It works as reverse vesting, since the shares are already issued.

How many founders are needed to incorporate a private limited company?

At least two shareholders and two directors. The same persons can be both.

Can a founder hold shares without being a director?

Yes. Shareholding and directorship are separate. A founder can be only a shareholder, only a director, or both.

Can founders get ESOPs?

Generally not if they are promoters or directors holding more than 10%, but a DPIIT-recognised startup can grant ESOPs to them for up to 10 years from incorporation.

Should the equity split be changed later?

It can be, through transfer of shares or fresh allotment, but each change has stamp duty, tax and valuation consequences. It is easier to agree on the split and vesting at the start.

ചുരുക്കം (Summary in Malayalam)

ഒന്നിലധികം പേർ ചേർന്ന് സ്റ്റാർട്ടപ്പ് തുടങ്ങുമ്പോൾ, ആരുടെ കൈവശം എത്ര ഓഹരി, ഒരു സ്ഥാപകൻ ഇടയ്ക്ക് പിരിഞ്ഞാൽ എന്ത് സംഭവിക്കും, നിക്ഷേപകർ എങ്ങനെ വരും എന്നിവ തുടക്കത്തിൽ തന്നെ തീരുമാനിക്കണം. നിക്ഷേപം പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കുന്നവർക്ക് പ്രൈവറ്റ് ലിമിറ്റഡ് കമ്പനിയാണ് സാധാരണ അനുയോജ്യം. 50:50 വിഭജനത്തിൽ തർക്കം ഉണ്ടായാൽ തീരുമാനമെടുക്കാൻ കഴിയാതെ വരാം. Reverse vesting, founders’ agreement, IP കമ്പനിയുടെ പേരിലേക്ക് മാറ്റൽ, ESOP pool എന്നിവ രേഖപ്പെടുത്തി വയ്ക്കുന്നത് പിന്നീട് തർക്കങ്ങളും നിക്ഷേപ സമയത്തെ പ്രശ്നങ്ങളും ഒഴിവാക്കും. വിദേശത്തുള്ള സ്ഥാപകർക്ക് FEMA നിയമങ്ങൾ ബാധകമാണ്.

This article gives a general overview of common practice and the law under the Companies Act, 2013, FEMA and related rules. Laws, rules and tax provisions are revised from time to time; for accurate and current requirements, refer to the Act, the rules as amended and the official notifications. The article is not advice on any particular case.

Please note. This article is provided for general information and is not professional advice or a solicitation of work. The law is stated as understood on the date shown above and may have changed since.